(NLJ) Ralph Wood–Orthodoxy, Orthopraxy, and Orthopathy: The Ecumenical Witness of the Wesleys for Church Life Today

The two Wesleys were especially concerned to honor the God of truth by maintaining true doctrine: orthodoxy. What we believe largely determines how we live. If we believe little or if we believe badly, we will become small-souled creatures and shrunken witnesses. Without clarity and conviction about our foundational beliefs, the Gospel degenerates into mere moral striving, a sort of civic club Christianity. The Wesleys rejected the notion that believers ought to check their brains at the church door. On the contrary, they regarded an unthoughtful Christian as an oxymoron, perhaps an ordinary moron. “It is a fundamental principle with us,” John Wesley wrote in a Catholic-inflected confession, “that to renounce reason is to renounce religion, that religion and reason go hand in hand, and that all irrational religion is false religion.”

As noted earlier, Charles and John Wesley were first-rate students and scholars, academic masters of languages and sciences alike. They were concerned that their followers be schooled in the best thought and art of their time. John thus wrote and published digests of several major Enlightenment thinkers, including David Hume and John Locke, in order that his followers would be able to engage their thought. He also sought to master the best science of his time, convinced that “the book of nature is written in an universal character, which every man may read in his own language.” He urged his followers to study the natural order as it was being newly opened up by modern science: “Life subsisting in millions of different forms,” John wrote, “shews the vast diffusion of [God’s] animating power, and death the infinite disproportion between [God] and every living thing.” There is little doubt that, if the Wesleys had lived in the nineteenth century rather than the eighteenth, they would have engaged the evolutionary biology of Charles Darwin—just as they would have sought, in our century, to integrate the physics of Einstein and Heisenberg into their theology. For the Wesleys, an anti-intellectual and anti-scientific faith is no faith at all but a form of religious cowardice.

What reason and revelation both teach, the Wesleys agreed, is that God remains radically transcendent and utterly other to us. God is not our chum and buddy, a heavenly step-and-fetch-it, a sacred Santa Claus who rewards us when we are not naughty but nice. God is not one being among the world’s other beings, not even the Supreme Being: God is the God who alone can identify himself. The theologians of Eastern Orthodoxy taught the Wesleys to understand God fundamentally as mystery and wonder. These words point not to an insoluble puzzle or intellectual conundrum but rather to God’s inexhaustible and unfathomable Reality. Hence our most accurate descriptions of God are apophatic, often more negative rather than positive: immortal, invisible, immutable, incorruptible, ineffable.

True doctrine must begin with the astonished wonder that the unknown God has made himself known in Jesus Christ. Orthodoxy thus honors the most staggering of paradoxes as it is articulated by the Fourth Lateran Council (1215): the more fully we comprehend God, the less fully have we comprehended him. Charles Wesley’s rousing hymn “Rejoice, the Lord is King” gets at this central ecumenical doctrine, which was also voiced by the greatest of Hebrew prophets: our ways are not God’s ways, and our thoughts not God’s thoughts (Isaiah 55:8). Nothing in heaven or on earth is to be worshipped. Like all things created, they are doomed to die. By refusing to make them our gods, we have hope for true victory:

Rejoice, the Lord is King! Your Lord and King adore;
Mortals, give thanks and sing, and triumph ever more.
Lift up your heart! lift up your voice!
Rejoice! again I say, rejoice!

The Wesley brothers were struck with wonder at one truth above all others, and it lies at the heart of their orthodoxy. 

Read it all.

Posted in Church History, Methodist, Theology

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.