Statement from the Russian Orthodox Church on the Church of Scotland Decision

concerning the decision of the Church of Scotland on a possible ordination of gay people in civil partnership and of the United Protestant Church of France on a possible blessing of the so called same-sex unions.
June 3rd, 2015

On May 16, 2015, the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland allowed ordination of gay people in civil partnership and on May 21 voted to continue the study of this matter aimed at an extension of the adopted decision. On May 17, the Synod of the United Protestant Church of France allowed a possibility of blessing the so called same-sex unions.

These decisions of the Protestant Churches of Scotland and France have deeply disappointed the Russian Orthodox Church as they seem incompatible with norms of Christian morality

We state with profound grief that today we have new divisions in the Christian world not only on theological problems, but also on the moral issues.
The Russian Orthodox Church holds the firm position based on Holy Scriptures and has repeatedly declared that the mentioned innovations were inadmissible for moral teaching and thus is ought to reconsider a format of her relations with the churches and associations which trample upon the principles of traditional Christian morality. In 2003, the Russian Orthodox Church suspended contacts with the Episcopal Church in the USA because this Church consecrated an open homosexual as bishop. Similar reasons have brought about the severance of relations with the Church of Sweden in 2005 when it decided to bless the same-sex unions.

During last years we have kept attentive watch over debates in the Churches of Scotland and France. In 2013, Metropolitan Hilarion of Volokolamsk, chairman of the Moscow Patriarchate’s Department for External Church Relations, sent a letter to the leadership of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland in which he expressed his anxiety and disappointment over a possibility of ordaining gay people and expressed hope that the consideration of this issue in future would be based on the apostolic tradition. Regrettably, these hopes have not been justified, and the words of warning have not been heard.

Guided by the resolutions of the Bishops’ Council of 2008, saying that ”˜the future of relations with many Protestant communities depends on their faithfulness to the norms of Gospel and apostolic morality kept by Christians over many centuries,’ and of the Bishops’ Council of 2013 saying that ”˜a dialogue with confessions which openly defy the Biblical moral norms is impossible,’ the Department for External Church Relations does not see any prospects in maintaining official contacts with the Church of Scotland and with the United Protestant Church of France.

Read it all

Posted in * Religion News & Commentary, Ecumenical Relations

11 comments on “Statement from the Russian Orthodox Church on the Church of Scotland Decision

  1. Katherine says:

    Elves, this ROC statement is dated June 3, 2015 (03.06.2015 on your link) and not July 3, 2015.

  2. Undergroundpewster says:

    A wise decision a copy of which should be nailed to the door of every Church of Scotland church and cathedral as well as the Episcopal churches here.

  3. CSeitz-ACI says:

    I actually do suspect the Scottish Episcopal Church will care and will take notice.

    They turned to the East after the reformation to establish an identity vis-à-vis the CofE. (Hence the epiclesis, etc).

  4. Ad Orientem says:

    Axios!

  5. Pageantmaster Ù† says:

    It is a warning to Justin Welby of the consequences which will result from the process he and David Porter have ‘designed’ for the Delphi Technique based ‘Facilited Conversations’ to follow the lead of the Church of Scotland and for which they have decreed that the Church of England will use the document which the Church of Scotland wrote and used to change its doctrine.

    It is also a warning to the CofE House of Bishops who have just met of the consequences which will flow from their decisions to go along with the Mengelian brain-washing techniques of this cold calculating Archbishop.

    Hubris and nemesis.

  6. Ad Orientem says:

    resubscribing… I don’t know why the first link in notification emails is to unsubscribe. arrggh

  7. GadgetVicar says:

    Sorry, Chris Seitz, but the SEC at its General Synod will today take the decision to go ahead with same-sex marriage regardless of what any other church might think.

    Feeling lonely in dissenting.

  8. Pageantmaster Ù† says:

    Well, it is likely to have consequences for the SEC within the Anglican Communion given what has been stated, not only for the SEC, but perhaps more serious is the undermining of the witness not to mention safety of Anglicans around the world:

    Global South Standing Committee [and see also follow up]

    both the decision to permit clergy to enter civil partnerships and this latest decision which some call it a “local option,” are wrong and were taken without prior consultation or consensus with the rest of the Anglican Communion at a time when the Communion is still facing major challenges of disunity. It is contrary to “the inter-dependence” which we try to affirm between churches within the Communion. Moreover, it does not only widen the gap between the Church of England and Anglicans in the Global South, it also widens the gap between the Anglican Communion and our ecumenical partners. Further, it jeopardizes the relationship between us Anglicans living in the Global South and followers of other faiths, and gives opportunities to exploit such departure of moral standards that this type of decision may provide.

    The Church, more than any time before, needs to stand firm for the faith once received from Jesus Christ through the Apostles and not yield to the pressures of the society! In other words, the Church needs to be “salt” and “light” and to present a distinctive message from that of the secular world around us.

    We strongly urge the Church of England to reconsider this divisive decision.

    + Mouneer Egypt and others

    and from here

    6. We note with great sadness the passing of Resolution A049 at the 77th General Convention of The Episcopal Church which authorized a liturgy for blessing same-sex unions. This action confirms our disappointment that The Episcopal Church has no regard for the concerns and convictions of the vast majority of Anglicans worldwide.

    7. We stand in solidarity with our brethren in the Communion Partners who have dissented from this action. We uphold them in prayer and support them in fellowship as they continue in their commitment to the evangelical faith and catholic order of the Church, as expressed in their Minority Report known as The Indianapolis Statement.

    8. We also appreciate and support all the faithful in Anglican Church in North America (ACNA) as well as those in the Anglican Church in Canada who remain true to our biblical and historic faith.

    GAFCON

    4.We commit ourselves to defend essential truths of the biblical faith even when this defence threatens existing structures of human authority (Acts 5:29). For this reason, the bishops at GAFCON 2013 resolved ‘to affirm and endorse the position of the Primates’ Council in providing oversight in cases where provinces and dioceses compromise biblical faith, including the affirmation of a duly discerned call to ministry. This may involve ordination and consecration if the situation requires.’

    5.We commit ourselves to the support and defence of those who in standing for apostolic truth are marginalized or excluded from formal communion with other Anglicans in their dioceses. We have therefore recognized the Anglican Mission in England (AMiE) as an expression of authentic Anglicanism both for those within and outside the Church of England, and welcomed their intention to appoint a General Secretary of AMiE.

    6.We commit ourselves to teach about God’s good purposes in marriage and in singleness. Marriage is a life-long exclusive union between a man and a woman. We exhort all people to work and pray for the building and strengthening of healthy marriages and families. For this reason, we oppose the secular tide running in favour of cohabitation and same-sex marriage.

    CAPA

    7- We are deeply concerned about the divisions within our beloved Anglican Communion. These divisions emerged when some Churches in the west allowed the worldly cultures, to reshape the message of church to the society especially in the area of marriage and human sexuality. These issues not only contradict the traditional teaching of the scripture but also impede our witness to the Gospel which is the reason of our presence in this world. We believe that the church is entrusted with the message of Gospel in order to transform the culture not the other way around. We do accept diversity but not diversity on the expense of the truth. Therefore we call upon these churches to refrain from making unilateral decisions which will further the divisions between the provinces of the Anglican Communion.

    8-We, by God’s Grace, continue to uphold the traditional biblical teaching in regard to human sexuality and marriage and affirm Lambeth Resolution 1:10 in its entirety. We believe that this is the only way to safeguard the life of the Christian families and we should resist the pressures of the secular western cultures to alter God’s purpose in creating Man and woman

    SEC is small, but it has great capacity to do damage to the witness of Anglicans around the world. Those voting today will not pay with their lives for the consequences of their actions.

    Prayers for the SEC, and for them to remain supportive of the Anglican witness.

  9. CSeitz-ACI says:

    #7. I am sorry to hear that, David. I had heard from a common friend in Fife that Kevin H was doing a good job alienating everyone. Very sad indeed. I was beginning to think the SEC was a rare liberal province with the capacity to move back from the brink.

  10. Pageantmaster Ù† says:

    Latest 2014 figures for SEC [page 67]:

    Membership: 32,634
    Attendance: 13,611

    Down from 41,000 in 2007 and 34,804 in 2012

    Oh dearie, dearie me.

  11. Jim the Puritan says:

    Another that has embraced sexual immorality and the worship of the Baals and has rejected and turned its back on Christ.