(WSJ) Charlotte Allen–Ben-Hur’s Watered-Down Christianity

While the filmmakers treat the Messiah with utmost reverence, he offers only a mix of platitudes about peace and forgiveness. This watered-down Christianity mirrors the sentiments of today’s fearful-to-offend evangelicalism, which often seems more concerned with wooing new followers than offering a complete understanding of Christianity’s demands and rewards.

“Love your enemies,” Jesus tells a young Judah. Later, he pacifies an angry mob of Jewish-nationalist Zealots with more boilerplate, telling them that violence against the oppressive Roman regime won’t solve anything. A few scenes later, an impressively costumed Morgan Freeman, playing the wealthy Sheikh Ilderim, who becomes Judah’s chariot-racing patron, also points out that violence isn’t the answer. If you’ve got Morgan Freeman, who needs Jesus?

Christ’s specifically salvific role, which made him the center of Christian theology for the past 2,000 years, goes missing in the film. As portrayed in “Ben-Hur,” he is neither the Messiah, nor the king whose kingdom is not of this world. Jesus’ death on the cross has no particular religious significance here. The Passion is depicted as almost accidental, as Jesus is swept up in Pontius Pilate’s broader purge of Zealots. Jesus’ death serves as nothing more than an opportunity to set a good example by forgiving his enemies.

Read it all (my emphasis).

print

Posted in * Culture-Watch, Christology, Movies & Television, Religion & Culture, Theology

One comment on “(WSJ) Charlotte Allen–Ben-Hur’s Watered-Down Christianity

  1. Jim the Puritan says:

    I was one of those who was manifestly disappointed with the “Bible” series (both Old and New Testaments) by Roma Downey and Mark Burnett. In the Old Testament series I stopped watching after viewing the Ninja Angels scene in Sodom. It was like what happens if you turn an action movie and CGI team lose on Scripture. Similarly the New Testament series was about 70 percent fiction, 30% from the Bible. I couldn’t take that one either.

    Anyway, I am guessing Ben Hur is more of the same and am not planning on going. Like so much of the stuff coming out of Hollywood, I figure it is just a warmed-over remake of the original with more action scenes and fake CGI thrown in.