Investors continued to flee Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac yesterday, almost as frantically as the political class tried to reassure everybody there was nothing to worry about. Allow us to sort the good (there isn’t much) from the ugly.
In the good category, Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson swatted back reports of a government “nationalization” of the companies ”“ which would mean making explicit what has long been an implicit taxpayer guarantee of their liabilities. This would instantly add $5 trillion in liabilities to the federal balance sheet, doubling the U.S. public debt burden and putting America’s AAA credit rating at risk. This is the nightmare scenario for taxpayers.
Less reassuringly, Mr. Paulson said, “our primary focus is supporting Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac in their current form as they carry out their important mission.” This suggests that Treasury thinks the two companies have enough capital, or can raise enough in private markets, to ride out any mortgage losses. We’re not so sure, and neither are investors, who have kept bidding Fan and Fred shares to new lows on fears of insolvency.
The most immediate danger is that investors will shrink from rolling over the debt of the two companies, leading to a run a la Bear Stearns. Mr. Paulson is trying to reassure people that the companies are sound, but after Bear everyone has the heebie-jeebies. With so much on the line, we’ve been suggesting that Treasury and Congress step up now with a public capital injection to help the companies ride out their losses.
The companies are not sound. They are insolvent. Their liabilities exceed their assets, they are broke. It’s just that we, the taxpayer, will bail them out because they are too big to fail.