WILLIAM GALSTON (Senior Fellow, Brookings Institution): Good to be back…[on the show]
{KIM] LAWTON: How does what happened in Afghanistan this week affect the moral calculus of how the US proceeds there?
GALSTON: In my judgment, this is a really tough one. On the one hand, as the defense secretary said, in the fog of war terrible things happen. To engage in a war is to commit yourself to a process that you can’t entirely control, and events like this unfortunately are almost inevitable. On the other hand, we are pursuing a kind of forward strategy, having our troops not just in the large bases but also interspersed with civilians in the countryside, and that makes it more likely that events of this sort will happen, but unfortunately the United States and its allies have reached the conclusion that this is the only way to prosecute the war with any chance of success. So now we have to choose between our strategy and the inevitable morally troubling consequences of that strategy.
Read it all.
Religion and Ethics Newsweekly–Moral Questions After Afghan Massacre
WILLIAM GALSTON (Senior Fellow, Brookings Institution): Good to be back…[on the show]
{KIM] LAWTON: How does what happened in Afghanistan this week affect the moral calculus of how the US proceeds there?
GALSTON: In my judgment, this is a really tough one. On the one hand, as the defense secretary said, in the fog of war terrible things happen. To engage in a war is to commit yourself to a process that you can’t entirely control, and events like this unfortunately are almost inevitable. On the other hand, we are pursuing a kind of forward strategy, having our troops not just in the large bases but also interspersed with civilians in the countryside, and that makes it more likely that events of this sort will happen, but unfortunately the United States and its allies have reached the conclusion that this is the only way to prosecute the war with any chance of success. So now we have to choose between our strategy and the inevitable morally troubling consequences of that strategy.
Read it all.