Declining membership hurts Episcopal churches in Northern California

She sings the litany. He delivers the sermon.

It is Sunday morning at All Saints Episcopal Church in Sacramento and both the Revs. Michael and Betsey Monnot preside over the worship services, one of several ways the church keeps down expenses.

“We trade off duties every week,” said Betsey Monnot.

The two priests, who are married and have two children and another due in three weeks, said the church could afford one full-time clergyperson. So they agreed to job-share and serve as co-rectors.

“When you’re a small church, you have to be creative,” said Michael Monnot.

Read it all.

Posted in * Anglican - Episcopal, * Christian Life / Church Life, Episcopal Church (TEC), Evangelism and Church Growth, Parish Ministry, TEC Data, TEC Parishes

10 comments on “Declining membership hurts Episcopal churches in Northern California

  1. evan miller says:

    I’m sure the U2 mass will have folks knocking down the doors to join the parish.

  2. A Senior Priest says:

    On the other hand, in that Diocese the congregations which are not shrinking, with decent revenues, Sunday Schools and youth ministries tend to be the more orthodox ones. In ten years most of the liberals will have drifted off or died of old age, their churches will have been closed and sold, and the orthodox will be most of who’s left.

  3. Dorpsgek says:

    But, things are probably very peaceful. No annoying clashes over theology.

    Seriously though, this all is heartrendingly painful to watch a once vibrant denomination go into such a death spiral over few years time. Never mind who caused it or why, it’s painful.

  4. Crypto Papist says:

    [blockquote] . . . the church could afford one full-time clergyperson. So they agreed to job-share and serve as co-rectors. [/blockquote]
    ASA barely over 50 and they somehow need two priests? I know of larger parishes with just one priest and a full schedule not just on Sundays but weekdays too. What do these folks do all day?

  5. Branford says:

    And then there’s my RC parish – 1,200 families and one priest (and two deacons)

  6. Philip Snyder says:

    I thought it interesting that Bishop Beisner actually admitted that +Robinson’s consecration cause some of the 18% ASA decline in 10 years.

    To attract people, TEC needs to be attractive. The fighting and lawsuits are not attractive. We also need to call people out of themselves and out of their self-focus and self-defined good. We need to call them to die to self and to be raised to new life in Jesus Christ.

    But that crude salvationism is passe among our denominational leadership – thus the declining numbers and death spiral of many congregations and dioceses.

    YBIC,
    Phil Snyder

  7. jamesw says:

    From the February 11, 2010 issue of the Diocesan clergy newsletter (go to diocesan website and look for either the “Latest Aurora Clergy E-News” or if its no longer there, go to “View e-Newsletter Archive here”).

    Dear friends in Christ:

    It should not come as a surprise to hear that some churches in the Diocese are struggling to maintain a full-time or even three-quarter time clergy. Or that some churches are having difficulty paying their basic obligations. In many cases it is loans from the Diocesan Endowment and Memorial Trust, group insurance premiums paid with Diocesan funds on behalf of churches, or Mission Apportionment that is left unpaid.

    Clergy and congregations are making heroic efforts to increase their membership and stewardship. In some instances these efforts have not resulted in the degree of success necessary to maintain sustainability. There are those who feel we are on the brink of a crisis which requires a response from the Office of the Bishop. This is because this is a crisis -not only for the congregation, but for all churches in the Diocese. We are strong when everyone is strong.

    At the Bishop’s direction, a group of concerned Board and Council members, along with staff, have formed the Church Response Work Group. This group consists of folks with expertise in pastoral issues, property issues, law, administration, and finance. When certain markers are identified, such as arrearages in obligations to the Diocese, reductions in the clergy person’s work week, or requests for special subsidies, a team will be appointed to make contact with the church and schedule a visit. The intent is to provide a holistic and integrative approach to identify core issues and assist the church in any reasonable way to address these issues effectively.

    The focus is on the health of the Diocese as a whole. Years of deficit budgets have depleted Diocesan resources to the point where we simply can’t continue to subsidize churches which appear unable to sustain themselves. After its latest meeting the group acknowledged that we don’t necessarily know how this is going to work. However, we believe that with right intention and a prayerful, collaborative approach we will find our way to a stronger Diocese built to last and to live out our mission to, “make disciples, raise up saints, and transform communities for Christ in Northern California.”

    With faith, hope and love,

    Canon Bobbi

  8. Cennydd says:

    You need look no further than the actions of your General Convention and your past three Presiding Bishops for the causes of your church’s distress.

  9. New Reformation Advocate says:

    jamesw (#7),
    Thanks for posting the revealing letter. At least Canon Bobbi admits the crisis is real, although the proposed remedy (a weak institutional committee) is ridiculously inadequate.

    Deacon Phil (#6),
    As usual, you’re right on target.

    David Handy+

  10. John316 says:

    [url=http://www.barna.org/barna-update/article/5-barna-update/196-evangelism-is-most-effective-among-kids]Evangelism Is Most Effective Among Kids[/url]

    A Barna study that I saw a few years back which basically says that barring a jailhouse conversion, evangelizing adults is very difficult.

    Ray Kroc and Walt Disney figured out half a century ago what mainline churches like this one have not. Kids bring their parents (and their parents bring the money), not the other way around. According to Fast Food Nation, there were 7200 McDonald’s with bright playgrounds in 2003. Coincidentally, that same year the ECUSA claimed 7200 churches. The numbers look different now of course, and in the mean time, while ECUSA has been closing churches, McD’s is building new playgrounds and rebuilding old ones. When a child goes in, he’s going to get a meal and a toy, and McD’s knows that all that investment in the children may well create a customer for life. When churches make that sort of effort with children, they make Christians for life and they kids bring the parents too.

    For the record, my kids take me to soccer games and McDonald’s, and they are bugging me to go to a Baptist church that they’ve visited with their friends.

    Luke 18:16